Quote Originally Posted by Jazzmarazz View Post
"Too cool for the job. Would probably freakin' rock at it."
this.
This is like saying a critic excels in the field at which they criticize.

Last I checked Ebert only had terrible films in his history, the Louvre wasn't hanging many paintings by renowned art critics, and Yahtzee's games were largely only "okay" from a gameplay perspective.

It's easy to point out how the other guy fucked up (especially when you have a team of writers). It's not easy to do a good job yourself.