
Originally Posted by
Aeolus Aeneas
So the other day, after several years I rewatched the first live action X-Men film, AKA Rogue and Wolverine: The Movie. It was actually rather shocking how little dialogue Storm had, especially when you look at the cut stuff and realize that about half of her spoken lines were all cut. It deviated heavily from the source, but it still did a pretty decent job... and I still wanted to see Wolvies classic outfit.
Then I watched the second film, which may have well been just called Wolverine: HERE YOU GO FANBOYS, because it was mostly just about him. Out of the original three films this felt the most like a comic book, I suppose, but it really just didn't work. I like Wolvie and all, but for a film called X-Men, I expected more X-Men... but hey, at least they didn't horribly butcher Nightcrawler. Too much.
And then we come to the third film... I honestly hated this one because it just did so much wrong. From what happened to Cyclops, the fate of Xavier, their take on Phoenix, the fact that for 95% of the film she was just standing there doing nothing at all, the ending itself, the fact that they changed Psylocke so much and had so little of her, they basically wrote Rogue out of the film completely... it was just one massive cluster of failure and bad ideas. But hey, at least Storm got some actual lines of dialogue this time around... at the cost of almost every other character.