It's probably the Dual Analog/Dual Shock family for me as well. Looking at the ol' genealogy, I can see how the Dreamcast worked well, but that second analog stick for camera or other works is really quite useful. The N64 was really awkward for simultaneous d-pad/analog use, which is probably the reason more games didn't insist on it. The old Atari remotes are kind of nostalgic, but I can't really call them good, per se, not when we've come this far since then. The Dual Shocks are just ergonomically superior, I think, and permit the use of all buttons fairly, with the possible exceptions of the L3/R3 buttons that few use.