Ah yes, as we all know. I mean, it's not like the industry has been the same since the Atari. It's not like there used to be no quality control and multiple consoles that were basically identical (pong consoles). It's not like there were unchecked 3rd party companies (tengen) releasing copies of games. It's not like 95%+ of old console game libraries are entirely unplayable or anything like that. Just had to ramble about that...now to get on topic...
Ftr SNES is just about to hit retro/vintage status. I say about 20 years, maybe 15 as a min. in which case it's already there. If you go off 20 years I have nothing but with 15 I've played a lot of SNES, Sega CD, Saturn and Playstation (Dreamcast not quite there yet
). Including PS1 any top list I make is going to be all PS1 so I'll include some non-sony console highlights...
Chrono Trigger
Nights into Dreams
Castlevania Rondo of Blood
Super Mario World
Super Metroid
As for my top games...
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (PS1)
What's to say...this is easily the best Castelvania game aside from Rondo of Blood which I would put right there with it which is saying a lot considering games like Aria of Sorrow are out there. Absolutely everything a Castlevania game should be.
Valkyrie Profile (PS1)
Well it's norse mythology in a video game that doesn't suck ass. Something I had been waiting quite awhile for. I actually got really lucky on my first playthrough and got the proper ending. I decided to check a guide when I was more than halfway through the game after I saw some stuff about a potentially bad ending. I checked the seal rating and found out it was too late to change anything but I was already locked in for the good ending. Speaking of which the final boss fight was balls. There is almost no way to grind in this game so you can't just overlevel. I had to set out Angel Curios on everyone and use Auto-Item: Angel Plume 100% to beat that shit...then the fun doesn't stop with the Seraphic gate. Lenneth + Brahms + Freya + Lezard = pro gate party.
Lunars (PS1)
Just gonna bundle up both of them here, and yes I know they were on other consoles but these are the definitive versions for me. Pretty much what got me in to rpgs. Classic cheesy jrpg shit but I love it. Too many classic moments to count. I took my forum name from it. ^^
Tactics Ogre (PS1)
Again the PS1 version is a port but it's better and in English. Pretty much the standard for srpgs imo and basically the precursor to FFT.
Vanguard Bandits (PS1)
Ooooh boy some great times with this game. Got my ass kicked by Faulkner a lot before I figured out some strats. My brother on his first playthrough didn't care about keeping people alive so he got the shit ending. I gotta admit that ending took us both off-guard, very messed up ending and something you probably wouldn't see nowadays...just all-around depressing. I then played out the game again and again to get all the endings. The weird, semi-hidden Ruin Branch is really out there but so worth doing once.
Some more I just wanna mention (all PS1)
Suikoden
Suikoden 2
Persona
Persona 2
Brigandine
Kartia
Dragon Quest 7
Star Ocean 2
Thousand Arms
Alundra